Midi Import

FarFromSubtle 14/09/2021 01:27

The Audio Importer web interface is very well designed and impressively seamless. I would love to see a similar implementation for midi clips. Right now the Midi2OSC app designed by Alex is serviceable but not ideal as even with wire connections on all devices there can be some issues with drifting notes and entire songs are quite fiddly to import.

• 

  SwarmHammer

  • 14/09/2021 05:08

  You can lookup for MIDI loopback application that would allow your DAW to send MIDI signals to another software, like midi2osc.

  0

  Пожаловаться на эту публикацию
• 

  TAPgiles

  • 14/09/2021 06:37

  

  Something that may help you is note-snapping, which snaps notes to the nearest proper timing. So timing drifts shouldn't affect the recording of the performance itself.

  0

  Пожаловаться на эту публикацию
• 

  FarFromSubtle

  • 15/09/2021 01:39

  SwarmHammer Midi2OSC is mentioned in the OP.

  TAPgiles Oh I have certainly tried. It is not an issue when bringing in a 4-8 bar segment, but for an entire complicated piano piece and attempting to save time by bringing in the whole song in one go? Even snapping can’t help and can even hinder as it does weird things to trills and other musical phrases that don’t adhere perfectly to the rhythm.

  0

  Пожаловаться на эту публикацию
• 

  thyon

  • 16/09/2021 06:21

  My guess is that there are thousands of MIDI versions of copyrighted songs out there and that would be very easy to import them. Covers are not allowed in many countries, because the actually written song melody is also copyrighted (not just the performer), so making it very easy will cause lots of rights issues. 

  0

  Пожаловаться на эту публикацию
• 

  FarFromSubtle

  • 17/09/2021 14:53
  • Изменен

  We have already seen any easy fix for right abuse with the audio editor. Restrict the tool to higher levels, and punish the abusers.

  1

  Пожаловаться на эту публикацию

Войдите в службу, чтобы оставить комментарий.